Painting vs Staining Your Home’s Exterior: Which Is Best for Brick Surfaces?

When it comes to upgrading your home’s exterior, brick surfaces offer both a unique opportunity and a distinct challenge. Brick is known for its timeless look and durability, but over time, you may want to refresh its appearance to boost curb appeal or better reflect your personal style. That leads many homeowners to ask: Should I paint or stain my brick?

At Springwater Painting, we’ve helped countless homeowners across Ontario and beyond make this important decision. Here’s a straightforward breakdown of the key differences between painting and staining brick—and how to decide which is right for your home.

Paint vs. Stain: What’s the Difference?

Appearance:
Paint delivers a bold, opaque finish that completely covers the brick’s original color and texture. It’s great for dramatic transformations—think white, black, grey, or bold modern tones. Stain, on the other hand, is more translucent. It enhances the natural color and texture of the brick rather than covering it completely, offering a more subtle and organic look.

Breathability:
Brick is naturally porous, and it needs to breathe. Stain soaks into the brick, allowing moisture to escape more easily and reducing the risk of damage from trapped water. Paint, if not applied properly, can seal the surface too tightly and trap moisture—especially risky in climates with freeze-thaw cycles like Ontario.

Durability and Maintenance:
Paint is long-lasting but may peel or chip over time, especially if the surface prep isn’t done correctly. It usually needs to be touched up or repainted every 7–10 years. Stain, while it doesn’t last quite as long (typically 5–8 years), tends to wear more naturally and requires less intensive upkeep since it won’t peel.

Cost and Prep Work:
Painting often comes with a higher upfront cost due to the extensive surface preparation it requires. This includes power washing, sealing, and priming the brick. Staining usually involves less prep—just a thorough cleaning—and is slightly more affordable depending on the condition of the brick.

When Painting Brick Makes Sense

Painting your brick is a great option if:

• You want a complete color transformation.
  
  
• The brick has already been painted (you can’t stain over paint).
  
  
• You want a smooth, uniform finish that hides imperfections or mismatched bricks.
  
  
• You’re okay with performing maintenance every decade or so.
  
  

Pros of Painting:

• Broad range of color choices
  
  
• Modern, updated appearance
  
  
• Seals and protects the brick surface
  
  

Cons of Painting:

• Can trap moisture if not properly applied
  
  
• May peel or chip over time
  
  
• Difficult to remove once done
  
  

When Staining Is the Better Choice

Staining is ideal if:

• You love the natural texture and character of your brick.
  
  
• Your brick is unpainted and in good condition.
  
  
• You want a subtle color enhancement, not full coverage.
  
  

Pros of Staining:

• Allows the brick to breathe naturally
  
  
• Less prone to peeling or chipping
  
  
• Lower maintenance over the years
  
  

Cons of Staining:

• Fewer color options compared to paint
  
  
• Doesn’t offer dramatic aesthetic changes
  
  
• Won’t conceal blemishes or patchy brickwork
  
  

Climate Matters: What to Consider in Ontario

Ontario’s weather brings freeze-thaw cycles that can cause moisture to build up behind sealed surfaces. This makes staining a popular choice, as it allows moisture to escape and reduces the risk of cracking or spalling. However, professionally applied breathable masonry paint can also hold up well—so long as the prep and application are done right.

What We Recommend at Springwater Painting

There’s no universal answer—it all depends on your home’s needs and your vision. Here's our rule of thumb:

• Go with stain if your brick is in great condition and you want to maintain its natural character.
  
  
• Go with paint if you're aiming for a bold transformation or need to cover up flaws in the brick.
  
  

Every project starts with a personalized consultation, where we assess your brick’s condition, listen to your goals, and recommend the best solution for lasting, beautiful results.

Ready to Refresh Your Brick Exterior?

At Springwater Painting, we specialize in both staining and painting brick exteriors. Whether you’re aiming to preserve historic charm or give your home a whole new look, our team is here to help—every step of the way.

‍